Yield Maintenance vs. Defeasance vs. Step-Down: Exit Math

Rate snapshot

Fed funds target3.75% to 4.00%Raised 25 bp at the Sept 16, 2026 FOMC meeting
5-year Treasury4.86%Sept 18, 2026 close, up 8 bp on the day. This is the reinvestment rate most yield maintenance formulas use
10-year Treasury5.01%Sept 18, 2026 close, up 5 bp from Sept 11
5-year Treasury, Sept 20210.83%Sept 20, 2021 close. The curve is 403 bp higher at that tenor today

The Treasury curve closed Friday with the 5-year at 4.86% and the 10-year at 5.01%, both higher after the FOMC raised the target range to 3.75% to 4.00% on September 16. Most of the commentary since has been about what higher-for-longer does to new originations. The more immediate money is sitting in loans that already exist.

Five years ago the 5-year Treasury was 0.83%. Sponsors who financed in 2021 locked note rates in the high 3s and low 4s, and a great many of those loans are now five years into a ten-year term with a prepayment provision attached. When those sponsors run an exit today, they tend to assume the prepayment penalty is a cost. On a 2021-vintage loan, it is often the opposite.

This post prices the same exit three ways: yield maintenance, defeasance, and a step-down schedule. The three structures are usually presented as a ranking that runs from cheapest to most punitive. At Friday’s curve, that ranking is upside down, and the gap between the best and worst outcome on a single $8.8 million balance is $542,306.

The finding: the ranking sponsors memorized in 2021 has inverted

The conventional ordering is that a step-down schedule is the friendliest prepayment provision, yield maintenance is worse, and defeasance is the one you accept only because the conduit execution priced better. That ordering held when Treasury yields were below note rates, because both yield maintenance and defeasance are functions of the gap between the two.

When Treasury yields sit above the note rate, both of those formulas break in the borrower’s favor. Yield maintenance collapses to its contractual floor. Defeasance goes further and produces a collateral cost below the loan balance. A step-down schedule does neither, because it is a fixed percentage that does not know or care where rates are.

On the loan modeled below, defeasance returns $266,394 to the sponsor at closing, yield maintenance costs $99,971, and the step-down costs $275,913. The structure that was supposed to be the borrower-friendly one is now the most expensive by a factor of two.

The loan

A Central Florida small-bay industrial property, 96,000 square feet, bought in September 2021. The loan is a ten-year fixed with a thirty-year amortization, and the sponsor has made exactly sixty payments. All figures below are computed from the amortization schedule and the September 18, 2026 Treasury par yield curve.

Loan and propertyValue
Purchase price, September 2021$15,000,000
Price per square foot$156.25
Original loan amount$9,750,000
Loan to value at closing65%
Note rate, fixed3.85%
Amortization30 years
Monthly payment$45,708.80
Principal amortized over 5 years$952,907
Balance after 60 payments$8,797,093
Scheduled balloon at month 120$7,642,263
Remaining obligation: 60 payments plus balloon$10,384,791

How each structure is actually computed

Yield maintenance

Yield maintenance makes the lender whole for the interest it will not receive. The standard construction takes the remaining scheduled payments, discounts them at a reinvestment rate tied to a Treasury of matching maturity, and charges the borrower the amount by which that present value exceeds the outstanding balance. Published lender formulas then apply a floor, and 1% of the prepaid principal is the market convention.

The floor is the whole story right now. Discounting this loan’s remaining payments at 4.86% produces a present value of $8,426,945 against a balance of $8,797,093. The raw calculation is negative $370,148, so the formula produces nothing and the 1% floor takes over at $87,971.

Defeasance

Defeasance does not pay off the loan. The borrower buys a portfolio of government securities whose payments replicate the remaining debt service and the balloon, substitutes that portfolio as collateral, and the lien on the real estate is released. The loan itself survives inside the securitization trust and is assumed by a successor borrower.

The governing constraint is tax law, not the loan documents. Treasury Regulation 26 CFR 1.860G-2(a)(8) permits a REMIC to release its lien only if the substitute collateral consists solely of government securities and the release is not within two years of the trust’s startup day. That two-year window is why defeasance lockouts exist at all.

Because the portfolio is priced off the Treasury curve, its cost moves inversely to yields. Discounting this loan’s $10,384,791 of remaining obligations across the September 18 curve produces a portfolio cost of $8,445,700, which is 96.01% of the outstanding balance.

Step-down

A step-down premium is a schedule. The loan modeled here carries a 5-5-4-4-3-3-2-2-1-1 structure, so an exit in loan year six costs 3% of the balance. There is no Treasury input, no floor, and no relief when the curve moves. That simplicity is exactly why it is now the expensive option.

What the three exits cost today

Exit structurePremium or portfolio vs. parTransaction costsNet cost to sponsor
Defeasance($351,394)$85,000($266,394)
Yield maintenance, 1% floor$87,971$12,000$99,971
Step-down, year 6 at 3%$263,913$12,000$275,913

The spread from best to worst is $542,306. That is 6.16% of the outstanding balance, 10.3% of the sponsor’s original equity, and $5.65 per square foot on a building that cost $156.25 per foot. None of it has anything to do with how the property performed.

Simplifications: the defeasance portfolio is priced by bootstrapping a zero curve from the interpolated September 18, 2026 Treasury par yields and discounting each monthly cash flow off that curve. An actual defeasance is executed against specific securities at live bid prices, so the real number will differ by some basis points. Transaction costs of $85,000 for defeasance (consultant, successor borrower, accountant verification, rating agency, legal, servicer) and $12,000 for an ordinary payoff are modeled assumptions, not quotes. The yield maintenance calculation uses the flat 5-year Treasury as the reinvestment rate with no added spread; documents that add a spread reduce the calculated premium further, which changes nothing here because the floor is already binding.

Where the crossovers sit

The inversion is not a permanent condition. It unwinds as the curve falls, and the crossover points are precise. Holding the loan and the schedule fixed and shifting the entire Treasury curve in parallel produces this grid.

Curve shift5-yr TreasuryDefeasance, netYield maintenance, netStep-down, netCheapest exit
-200 bp2.86%$474,949$392,627$275,913Step-down
-150 bp3.36%$282,412$198,132$275,913Yield maintenance
-100 bp3.86%$94,768$99,971$275,913Defeasance
-50 bp4.36%($88,122)$99,971$275,913Defeasance
0 bp (Sept 18, 2026)4.86%($266,394)$99,971$275,913Defeasance
+50 bp5.36%($440,175)$99,971$275,913Defeasance
+100 bp5.86%($609,594)$99,971$275,913Defeasance

Four thresholds are worth writing down. The defeasance portfolio costs exactly par when the 5-year Treasury reaches 3.89%, and the net defeasance exit, after transaction costs, breaks even at 4.12%.

Defeasance and yield maintenance cost the same at 3.85%, which is the note rate itself and not a coincidence. Defeasance stops beating the step-down at 3.38%.

The 5-year Treasury closed Friday at 4.86%. It would need to fall 74 basis points before a defeasance exit stops being free, and 148 basis points before the step-down schedule becomes the better provision to have signed.

The same exit at four note-rate vintages

Change nothing except the note rate and the picture rotates through all three structures. This is the cleanest way to see which prepayment provision you should want, given when you borrowed.

Note rateBalance at month 60Defeasance portfolioPortfolio vs. parDefeasance netYield maint. netStep-down netCheapest
3.85% (2021)$8,797,093$8,445,700($351,394)($266,394)$99,971$275,913Defeasance
4.50%$8,887,897$8,773,485($114,412)($29,412)$100,879$278,637Defeasance
5.25%$8,984,575$9,152,616$168,041$253,041$159,529$281,537Yield maintenance
6.25%$9,100,381$9,658,306$557,925$642,925$548,140$285,011Step-down

Each row is the same $9,750,000 loan, thirty-year amortization, five years elapsed, priced against the same September 18 curve. The only variable is the note rate. Defeasance is the cheapest exit on the low-rate vintages, yield maintenance wins in the middle, and the step-down schedule only becomes the borrower-friendly provision once the note rate is well above the curve.

The practical reading: if you are quoting a new fixed-rate loan today at a rate near or above the 5-year Treasury, a step-down is genuinely the provision to negotiate for. If you are sitting on 2021 paper, it is the one you least want to have.

A negative penalty is not free money

The $266,394 is real, but it is easy to misread what it represents. The defeasance portfolio costs less than par for exactly one reason: the loan pays 3.85% in a market that no longer does. That below-market coupon is an asset the sponsor already owns, and defeasing simply converts it to cash.

Run the same loan against an assumed market replacement rate of 6.75%. The present value of the remaining payments falls to $7,780,505, which makes the embedded value of that debt $1,016,589, or 11.56% of the balance. Refinancing the same $8,797,093 at 6.75% on a thirty-year schedule raises the monthly payment from $45,709 to $57,058, which is $136,188 more per year and $680,939 over five years.

So the defeasance discount of $266,394 is worth capturing only if the sponsor was exiting the asset anyway. Defeasing in order to refinance the same property surrenders roughly $1.0 million of embedded value to collect $266,394. That is not a close call.

There is a timing wrinkle on the other side. Defeasance obligations end when the loan enters its open period, typically three to four months before maturity, after which the loan prepays at par with no penalty. A borrower who waits for the open period to avoid a penalty gets a penalty of zero, which is worse than the negative penalty available today. The discount has an expiration date.

What to check before you assume any of this applies

  1. Confirm which provision you actually have. Term sheets say “yield maintenance or defeasance” more often than loan documents do. Pull the note and read the prepayment section.
  2. Find the yield maintenance floor and how it is expressed. A floor stated as 1% of the prepaid principal behaves very differently from one stated as a minimum number of months of interest.
  3. Find the reinvestment rate definition. Whether the document uses a Treasury yield flat, a Treasury plus a spread, or a rate selected by the lender changes the calculation and, in a few documents, removes the borrower’s ability to verify it.
  4. Check the lockout. Under the REMIC rules a securitized loan cannot be defeased within two years of the trust’s startup day, and many documents extend that period well past the regulatory minimum.
  5. Read who keeps the residual. Timing mismatches between the securities and the loan payments generate interest, and whether the borrower, the successor borrower, or the servicer ends up with it is a negotiated point that is frequently not negotiated.
  6. Ask whether agency securities are permitted, not just Treasuries. A broader definition of eligible collateral generally produces better portfolio pricing.
  7. Check the permitted final payment date. A portfolio that can be structured to the start of the open period rather than the maturity date is materially cheaper.
  8. Get the defeasance cost quoted by a consultant running a competitive auction rather than accepting a lender-selected portfolio, and get it in writing before you sign a purchase and sale agreement.

The red flag to watch for is a purchase and sale agreement negotiated on the assumption that the prepayment penalty is a seller cost of roughly 1% to 3%. On a 2021-vintage loan that assumption can be off by half a million dollars in the seller’s favor, and a buyer’s counsel who understands the math will price it into the contract if the seller does not.

How QuadBlock can help

QuadBlock Capital provides bridge, transitional, and permanent financing from $250,000 to $30 million across multifamily, industrial, retail, self-storage, specialty, and ground-up residential, in every state except Oregon and Nevada. If you are weighing an exit on a low-coupon loan, we will run the prepayment math against the current curve alongside the refinance and hold cases so you can see all three side by side. Send the note, the current balance, and your target closing date through quadblockcapital.com and we will come back with numbers.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Defeasance and yield maintenance provisions are governed by the specific language of your loan documents, and defeasance carries federal income tax consequences that vary with the structure of the transaction and the ownership entity. The REMIC rules discussed are summarized, not reproduced. Consult your own counsel and tax advisor before acting on any prepayment strategy. Market rates and modeled transaction costs are illustrative assumptions and are not offers or quotes from QuadBlock Capital.

Sources

  1. U.S. Department of the Treasury, Daily Treasury Par Yield Curve Rates, September 2026
  2. U.S. Department of the Treasury, Daily Treasury Par Yield Curve Rates, September 2021
  3. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Open Market Operations: FOMC target rate history
  4. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, H.15 Selected Interest Rates
  5. 26 CFR 1.860G-2, Other rules (REMIC lien release and defeasance), Legal Information Institute
  6. The Counselors of Real Estate, Negotiating Defeasance Provisions at Origination Can Materially Impact the Bottom Line
  7. Greystone, Yield Maintenance 101
  8. Pensford, Negative Defeasance: Use It or Lose It
Scroll to Top