Loan Assumption vs. New Financing: The Blended Cost of Capital

Rate snapshot

Fed funds target range3.75% to 4.00%Raised 25 bp September 16, 2026
10-year Treasury5.11%September 23 close, the latest available print
5-year Treasury4.99%September 23 close; 12 bp inside the 10-year
New agency coupon versus assumed coupon329 bp6.91% new money against the 3.62% loan modeled below

With the 10-year at 5.11%, a seller carrying a 3.62% agency loan from 2021 is sitting on something that looks like free money. Buyers are chasing these deals, brokers are marketing them, and the pitch writes itself: assume the loan, inherit the coupon, save 329 basis points.

On the 96-unit deal modeled below, assuming that 3.62% loan is worth negative $395,557 compared with simply taking new debt at 6.91%. The coupon saving is real, $1,897,175 of interest over the five years left on the loan. It is smaller than the cost of the $2,083,655 of additional equity the assumption forces the buyer to leave in the deal.

That is the trade nobody prices. A five-year-old loan has amortized down, and the balance is the balance. You cannot assume more than what is outstanding. So the cheap coupon comes attached to low leverage, and low leverage on a purchase means writing a bigger equity check at a time when equity is the most expensive money in the stack.

The deal and the in-place loan

A 96-unit multifamily property in a Sun Belt secondary market, under contract at $13,400,000 with in-place NOI of $938,000, a 7.00% going-in cap. The seller financed it in September 2021 with an $8,100,000 agency loan at 3.62%, ten-year term, thirty-year amortization. Five years have run.

The seller’s loanValue
Original loan amount, September 2021$8,100,000
Coupon3.62%
Monthly payment$36,917
Annual debt service$443,008
Balance today, after 60 payments$7,280,349
Years remaining on term5.0
Remaining amortization25 years
Balance as a share of purchase price54.3%
DSCR on the assumed loan2.12x

A 2.12x DSCR is not a compliment. It means the property is carrying far less debt than it can support, which is exactly the problem. The loan is safe and small. The buyer has to make up the difference.

What new debt would size to today

Assume a 180 basis point agency spread over the 10-year for a new ten-year fixed loan on a thirty-year schedule. At today’s print that is 6.91%. Three tests run and the lowest wins.

ConstraintSupported loanBinding
70% loan to value on $13,400,000$9,380,000Yes
1.25x DSCR at 6.91%, thirty-year amortization$9,485,251No
8.5% debt yield on $938,000 of NOI$11,035,294No
Supported new loan$9,380,000

New debt at 6.91% delivers $9,380,000. The assumable loan delivers $7,280,349. The gap is $2,099,651 of proceeds, and it has to come from somewhere.

Three ways to capitalize the same purchase

Option C adds a supplemental loan behind the assumed first, sized so combined coverage lands at 1.25x. Agency programs contemplate supplementals precisely for this situation.

A. Assume onlyB. New 10-year loanC. Assume plus supplemental
Total uses$14,180,803$14,196,800$14,214,553
Financing fees inside total uses$77,803$93,800$111,553
Assumed agency loan at 3.62%$7,280,349$0$7,280,349
New agency loan at 6.91%$0$9,380,000$0
Supplemental loan at 8.36%$0$0$3,374,902
Total debt at close$7,280,349$9,380,000$10,655,251
Equity required$6,900,455$4,816,800$3,559,302
Equity as a share of total cost48.7%33.9%25.0%
Annual debt service$443,008$742,073$750,400
Combined DSCR2.12x1.26x1.25x
Cash flow after debt service$494,992$195,927$187,600
Blended cost of capital at 16% equity9.64%9.99%7.85%

The blended cost of capital row is the one to read. Option A, the cheap coupon everyone wants, comes in at 9.64%. Option B, the expensive new loan, comes in at 9.99%. Those are 35 basis points apart, not 329. The coupon advantage nearly vanishes once you weight it by how little of the stack it covers.

Option C is the actual answer at 7.85%, almost two full points cheaper than either single-instrument option. It keeps the 3.62% money and adds leverage on top, which is what the coupon advantage was supposed to buy in the first place.

Is the cheap coupon worth the extra equity?

Compare Options A and B over a common horizon: the five years left on the assumed loan. After that both borrowers refinance into whatever the market offers, so the comparison is clean.

Five-year comparison, Option A versus Option BAmount
Interest paid, Option A ($7,280,349 at 3.62%)$1,254,189
Interest paid, Option B ($9,380,000 at 6.91%)$3,151,364
Interest saved by assuming$1,897,175
Extra equity tied up under Option A$2,083,655
Opportunity cost of that equity at 16% over 5 years$2,292,732
Net advantage of assuming-$395,557

The interest saving is large and it still loses. Compounding $2,083,655 at 16% for five years costs $2,292,732 of forgone return, which is $395,557 more than the coupon saves. A sponsor whose equity has nowhere better to go should assume. A sponsor with a pipeline should not.

Simplifications: a 180 basis point agency spread over the 10-year and a 325 basis point spread for the supplemental, held flat; 1.00% origination on new and supplemental debt; a 1.00% transfer fee plus a $5,000 review fee on the assumption. In-place NOI is held flat with no growth and no lease-up. The opportunity cost of equity is modeled as simple compounding at the stated rate, which is a proxy for the sponsor’s next-best use of capital rather than a promoted return. Prepayment cost on the seller’s loan (yield maintenance or defeasance) is excluded because it is the seller’s expense, though in practice it moves the purchase price. Transfer and recording taxes, third-party reports and escrows are excluded. Exit is not modeled, so the residual value of a below-market loan at resale is not credited to Option A.

Where the answer flips

The verdict depends almost entirely on two numbers: what the buyer’s equity is worth, and where new debt prices. Here is the net advantage of assuming across both.

Cost of the buyer’s equityNew loan 5.91%6.41%6.91%7.41%7.91%
8%$448,402$683,491$919,258$1,192,559$1,453,762
10%$154,227$389,316$625,083$948,316$1,269,217
12%-$162,138$72,952$308,718$685,649$1,070,751
14%-$501,925-$266,836-$31,069$403,535$857,591
16%-$866,413-$631,324-$395,557$100,914$628,937
18%-$1,256,923-$1,021,834-$786,068-$223,314$383,957
20%-$1,674,826-$1,439,737-$1,203,970-$570,284$121,794

At a 6.91% alternative, the crossover sits between a 12% and a 14% cost of equity. Below that, assume. Above it, do not. Note what happens reading right along the 16% row: once new debt reaches 7.41% the assumption wins again, because the alternative got expensive enough to justify the equity drag. The decision is a horse race between two prices, not a verdict on 3.62%.

The gate that actually stops these deals

Pricing is the part buyers model. Qualification is the part that kills the timeline. Freddie Mac publishes its guarantor tests, and they are not negotiable at the margin.

Freddie Mac test on this assumptionRequirement
Assumed loan amount$7,280,349
Minimum net worth of the new guarantor, loan at or under $15M$5,000,000
Minimum liquidity, 100% of annual debt service$443,008
Minimum liquidity, 10% of total loan amount$728,035
Binding liquidity requirement (the greater of the two)$728,035
Transfer review fee, requests submitted after March 31, 2011$5,000
Transfer fee modeled at 1.00% of UPB$72,803
Total assumption cost modeled$77,803

Freddie’s published requirement is a “Minimum net worth of proposed New Guarantor must be the greater of: $5 million if loan amount is less than or equal to $15M; $10M if greater than $15M but less than $30M,” with minimum liquidity of “the greater of: 100% of annual debt service; 10% of total loan amount.” Those verifications must be in the names of the individual or entity guarantors, not an affiliate.

Freddie also publishes the clock. Its servicer guidance states the process takes “30 calendar days once a complete package is submitted,” and Chapter 41 of the Seller/Servicer Guide requires the servicer to submit the package “at least 15 days prior to the proposed date of the Transfer of Ownership.” The complete package is long: executed sales contract, financial statements and credit reports for the transferee and its principals, organizational charts, Forms 1115 and 1116, manager information, evidence of insurance, certified property financials, a year-one budget, a moisture management plan, and third-party reports where applicable.

Fannie Mae’s equivalent is a 1% transfer fee. Its transfer and assumption form provides for “1% of the Unpaid Principal Balance as of the anticipated effective date of the Transfer/Assumption, to be shared equally by the Servicer and Fannie Mae,” plus a $3,000 review fee which “the Servicer may increase or decrease at its discretion.” That $3,000 is a default, not a cap.

A fee caveat worth reading your note for

The 1% transfer fee is widely quoted as an agency standard. It is documented as a flat percentage for Fannie, and for Freddie loans written before July 1, 2014. For Freddie loan documents revised on or after July 1, 2014, Exhibit 10 does not state a percentage at all. It says the transfer fee is “As specified in Loan Documents.”

The loan modeled here was originated in 2021, which puts it squarely in that category. Anyone underwriting a Freddie assumption on modern paper has to read the note and loan agreement to find the number. Assuming 1% because that is what the internet says is how a $72,803 line item turns into a surprise.

One thing that does not apply to you

Buyers who have read about residential real estate sometimes ask about taking title subject to the existing debt rather than assuming it. In commercial real estate that is a dead end, and the reason is statutory.

The Garn-St Germain Act at 12 U.S.C. 1701j-3(b)(1) provides that “a lender may, subject to subsection (c), enter into or enforce a contract containing a due-on-sale clause with respect to a real property loan.” Subsection (d) then lists the transfers a lender may not accelerate on, and that protected list applies exclusively to residential real property containing fewer than five dwelling units. A 96-unit apartment property is nowhere near that line.

So on this deal the due-on-sale clause is fully enforceable and there is no federal safe harbor. A lender-consented assumption is the only compliant path, and it is also the only one that releases the seller, which is why the agencies document it with a release instrument.

Checklist for pricing an assumption

  1. Get the current balance, not the original loan amount. Five years of amortization is the whole reason the math is close.
  2. Model what new debt would size to on the same asset, at today’s curve. You cannot price an assumption without the alternative.
  3. Put a number on your cost of equity before you start. The sensitivity table above flips on that input and nothing else.
  4. Price the supplemental option explicitly. On this deal it was the cheapest capital structure by almost two points and neither headline option came close.
  5. Read the note for the transfer fee rather than assuming 1%, especially on Freddie paper originated after July 2014.
  6. Test your guarantor against the published net worth and liquidity minimums before you spend money on diligence.
  7. Build the 30-day agency clock, plus the 15-day submission lead time, into the contract. Then add time for the package to actually be complete, because the clock starts when it is.
  8. Ask who pays the seller’s prepayment cost if the assumption fails. That answer belongs in the contract, not in a phone call in week six.

How QuadBlock can help

QuadBlock Capital provides bridge, transitional and permanent financing from $250,000 to $30 million on multifamily, industrial, retail, self-storage, specialty assets and ground-up SFR and townhome communities, in every state except Oregon and Nevada. Assumption deals usually need a second piece of capital behind the assumed loan to make the leverage work, and that is a conversation worth having before you sign the contract rather than after. Send the deal and the existing loan terms to us at quadblockcapital.com and we will price the gap.

This article is for general educational purposes and is not tax, legal, or investment advice, and it is not a rate quote or a commitment to lend. Agency assumption fees, guarantor requirements, timelines and package contents are summarized from the published sources listed below as of the dates those documents carry, and they change; the governing terms for any specific loan are in that loan’s own documents. Spreads, coupons, cost of equity, DSCR, LTV and debt yield assumptions in the worked example are illustrative modeling inputs, not quoted terms. Nothing here is a forecast of future interest rates. Consult your own counsel and tax advisor on any assumption, transfer or due-on-sale question. All figures in the worked example are illustrative and do not represent QuadBlock Capital loan terms, pricing, or leverage.

Sources

  1. U.S. Department of the Treasury, Daily Treasury Par Yield Curve Rates, September 2026
  2. Federal Reserve, FOMC statement, September 16, 2026
  3. Freddie Mac Multifamily Seller/Servicer Guide, Chapter 41, Transfers of Ownership
  4. Freddie Mac Multifamily, Exhibit 10, Lender Review, Processing and Consent Fee Schedule
  5. Freddie Mac Multifamily, Common Misses on Loan Assumption Submissions
  6. Freddie Mac Multifamily, Approach to Loan Assumption Requests
  7. Freddie Mac Multifamily, Providing a Better Borrower Assumption Process
  8. Fannie Mae Multifamily, Form 4636.T/A, Transfer/Assumption loan document modifications
  9. 12 U.S.C. section 1701j-3, Preemption of due-on-sale prohibitions
  10. Mortgage Bankers Association, 17 Percent of Commercial and Multifamily Mortgage Balances to Mature in 2026
Scroll to Top