Rate snapshot
| Fed funds target | 3.75% to 4.00% | raised 25 bp Sept 16, 2026 |
| 5-year Treasury | 5.02% | Oct 9, 2026 close, up 3 bp on the day |
| 10-year Treasury | 5.24% | Oct 9, 2026 close, up 2 bp on the day |
| 2s/10s spread | +44 bp | 2-year at 4.80%, Oct 9, 2026 |
Monday was a bond market holiday, so Friday’s close is still the freshest print on the curve: the 5-year at 5.02% and the 10-year at 5.24%. With the FOMC meeting October 27 and 28, a sponsor pricing a five-year fixed loan this week is working off a stale print with a policy decision in front of it. The structural question most sponsors get wrong in that setup is not the rate. It is the amortization.
Here is the finding that surprises most people who run it for the first time. On a stabilized small-bay industrial acquisition at a 6.50% going-in cap, the interest-only structure produces a loan that is $809,726 larger than the amortizing structure and costs $15,625 per year less to service. Bigger loan, smaller payment. That is not a pricing trick and it is not a lender doing you a favor.
It happens because the two structures collide with different constraints. The amortizing loan is capped by DSCR and never reaches the LTV ceiling. The interest-only loan clears DSCR easily and gets stopped by LTV instead, at a dollar amount whose interest-only payment sits below the DSCR ceiling. Understanding which test is binding on your deal tells you whether interest-only is worth asking for at all, and the answer is frequently no.
Why interest-only changes loan size in the first place
A DSCR test does not limit your loan balance. It limits your annual debt service. The lender decides how many dollars of payment your NOI can cover, then works backward to a principal amount using whatever payment structure the loan has.
With a 30-year amortizing loan at 7.25%, every dollar of principal carries 8.186 cents of annual debt service. That figure is the loan constant, and it is the only number that converts a payment ceiling into a loan amount. With interest-only at the same rate, every dollar of principal carries 7.25 cents. The same payment capacity therefore buys about 13% more principal under interest-only.
Note the second-order point in that loan constant. At 8.186%, the amortizing payment per dollar of debt exceeds the 6.50% going-in cap rate on the property. Amortizing debt on this deal is negative leverage in cash flow terms from day one, which is exactly why the DSCR test bites so early.
The deal: stabilized small-bay industrial
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | $12,500,000 |
| In-place NOI | $812,500 |
| Going-in cap rate | 6.50% |
| Fixed rate, 5-year term | 7.25% |
| Amortization schedule | 30 years |
| Maximum LTV | 70% |
| Minimum DSCR | 1.25x |
| Minimum debt yield | 9.0% |
| NOI growth assumption | 3.0% per year |
| Acquisition closing costs | 2.0% of price |
The sizing waterfall
Run all three tests against both structures. The loan is the lowest number in the column, not the average and not the one your lender quoted first.
| Test | Amortizing | Interest-only |
|---|---|---|
| 70% LTV ceiling | $8,750,000 | $8,750,000 |
| 9.0% debt yield ceiling | $9,027,778 | $9,027,778 |
| 1.25x DSCR ceiling | $7,940,274 | $8,965,517 |
| Loan amount (lowest test) | $7,940,274 | $8,750,000 |
| Binding constraint | DSCR | LTV |
| Resulting LTV | 63.5% | 70.0% |
| Equity at close | $4,809,726 | $4,000,000 |
Two things in that table deserve attention. First, the amortizing borrower leaves 6.5 points of LTV on the table. They are not at 70% leverage because DSCR stopped them at 63.5%, and no amount of negotiating the LTV cap would change that.
Second, and this is the part sponsors miss: the interest-only DSCR test would have supported $8,965,517, but the LTV ceiling stops the loan at $8,750,000. That means $215,517 of the DSCR relief interest-only bought you is unusable. The marginal value of interest-only is never the full DSCR improvement. It is capped by whichever test is next in line, and on a deal with a low enough cap rate, that next test arrives quickly.
Simplifications: one fixed rate across structures, no rate adjustment for the higher-leverage interest-only loan, no reserves or escrows modeled, NOI growth constant at 3.0%, no lease rollover or capital expenditure timing, and no origination fees in the equity figures. A real quote would likely price the 70% LTV interest-only loan wider than the 63.5% LTV amortizing loan, which narrows the advantage shown here.
The structure that borrows more and pays less
Because the amortizing loan is sized to the exact DSCR ceiling, its annual debt service is $650,000 by construction. The interest-only loan, stopped by LTV at $8,750,000, carries annual interest of $634,375. The larger loan has the smaller payment.
| Year | NOI | DS amortizing | Cash flow | DSCR | DS interest-only | Cash flow | DSCR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $812,500 | $650,000 | $162,500 | 1.25x | $634,375 | $178,125 | 1.28x |
| 2 | $836,875 | $650,000 | $186,875 | 1.29x | $634,375 | $202,500 | 1.32x |
| 3 | $861,981 | $650,000 | $211,981 | 1.33x | $634,375 | $227,606 | 1.36x |
| 4 | $887,841 | $650,000 | $237,841 | 1.37x | $634,375 | $253,466 | 1.40x |
| 5 | $914,476 | $650,000 | $264,476 | 1.41x | $634,375 | $280,101 | 1.44x |
| Total | $4,313,673 | $3,250,000 | $1,063,673 | $3,171,875 | $1,141,798 |
On smaller equity, the interest-only structure also produces better cash-on-cash: 4.45% in year one against 3.38%, and 5.71% on average across the hold against 4.42%. Every operating metric favors interest-only. The entire cost of the structure is deferred to one line item that does not appear anywhere in the table above.
| Position at end of year 5 | Amortizing | Interest-only |
|---|---|---|
| Loan balance | $7,493,934 | $8,750,000 |
| Principal retired | $446,340 | $0 |
| Balance difference | $1,256,066 |
What the extra $809,726 actually costs
The interest-only borrower received $809,726 more at closing and $15,625 more per year in cash flow. In exchange they owe $1,256,066 more at the end of year five. That $1,256,066 is the $809,726 they borrowed plus the $446,340 of principal the amortizing borrower retired.
So the question has a precise answer. Solve for the annual return at which the $809,726 of day-one cash, compounded alongside the $15,625 annual cash flow advantage, grows to $1,256,066 over five years. That rate is 7.55%.
If the sponsor can reliably put that $809,726 to work above 7.55%, interest-only wins. If the money sits in a money market account, or funds a capital item that would have been funded anyway, or simply reduces the equity check without being redeployed into anything, interest-only loses. Note that 7.55% sits above the 7.25% loan rate, which is the intuition worth keeping: deferring principal is not free financing, it is financing at slightly worse than your coupon once you account for the compounding you gave up.
The exit, two ways
A five-year hold ends in a sale or a refinance, and interest-only behaves very differently in each. On a sale, the structure is close to neutral and the exit cap rate decides the winner.
| Exit cap | Exit value | Profit amortizing | Profit interest-only | IRR amortizing | IRR interest-only |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.00% | $15,241,265 | $3,772,660 | $3,404,444 | 12.99% | 14.09% |
| 6.50% | $14,068,860 | $2,617,841 | $2,249,625 | 9.66% | 10.11% |
| 7.00% | $13,063,942 | $1,627,996 | $1,259,780 | 6.42% | 6.15% |
| 7.50% | $12,193,012 | $770,130 | $401,915 | 3.25% | 2.14% |
Total dollar profit is always higher for the amortizing borrower, because they financed less and paid down principal. IRR flips, because the interest-only borrower put in $809,726 less equity. Interest-only wins on IRR when the exit cap holds at or below roughly 6.50% and loses when cap rates expand to 7.00% or beyond. That crossover is the honest summary of the sale case: interest-only is a bet that values hold.
The refinance case is where the structure stops being a close call. Hold the exit cap at 7.00%, size a new 30-year loan on Year-5 NOI of $914,476 against the same three tests, and vary the refinance rate.
| Refi rate | Max new loan | Cash in, amortizing | Cash in, interest-only |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7.25% | $8,936,848 | $0 | $0 |
| 8.00% | $8,308,531 | $0 | $441,469 |
| 8.75% | $7,749,463 | $0 | $1,000,537 |
| 9.50% | $7,250,372 | $243,561 | $1,499,628 |
At an 8.75% takeout rate, the interest-only borrower writes a $1,000,537 check to refinance a performing asset whose NOI grew every year of the hold. The amortizing borrower writes nothing. The $809,726 pocketed at closing comes back as a larger number five years later, at the least convenient moment, and it has to be funded from somewhere other than the property.
Worth noting which test produces that result. In every row of the table, the binding constraint on the new loan is DSCR, not LTV. The property is worth $13,063,942 and 70% of that is $9,144,759, comfortably above both balances. Rates, not values, are what shut down the refinance. A sponsor who stress-tests only the exit cap rate and not the exit rate will not see this coming.
Partial interest-only and the convention that decides everything
Most middle-market quotes land somewhere in between: two or three years of interest-only, then amortization for the balance of the term. Whether that structure buys you any proceeds depends entirely on one underwriting convention that rarely appears in a term sheet.
Some lenders run the DSCR test on the actual interest-only payment during the interest-only period. Others run it on a notional amortizing payment for the whole term, regardless of when amortization starts. On this deal the difference is $809,726 of day-one proceeds, which is the entire gap between the two structures above.
| Structure, 2 years IO then 28-year amortization | Value |
|---|---|
| Loan sized on amortizing constant | $7,940,274 |
| Annual debt service, years 1 and 2 | $575,670 |
| DSCR, years 1 and 2 | 1.41x |
| Annual debt service, years 3 to 5 | $663,321 |
| Payment step-up in year 3 | $87,651 (15.2%) |
| Year-3 NOI | $861,981 |
| DSCR after step-up | 1.30x |
| Balance at year 5 | $7,647,516 |
| Cash in to refinance at 8.75% | $0 |
Sized conservatively, the partial interest-only structure delivers no extra proceeds at all: the loan is the same $7,940,274 as the fully amortizing case. What it delivers is $74,330 per year of extra cash flow for two years and a 15.2% payment step-up in year three that your pro forma needs to survive. Here NOI growth absorbs it and DSCR only falls to 1.30x, but a deal with flat NOI and a tighter going-in coverage would trip a covenant on the step-up date.
The practical takeaway is that partial interest-only is a cash flow tool, not a proceeds tool, unless your lender sizes on the interest-only payment. Ask which convention applies before you build the model.
How to run this on your own deal
- Compute the loan constant at your quoted rate and amortization. Compare it to the going-in cap rate. If the constant is higher, DSCR will bind before LTV and interest-only may move your proceeds.
- Run all three tests separately for amortizing and interest-only. Write down which test is lowest in each case.
- If LTV or debt yield is already binding under amortization, stop. Interest-only will not increase your loan by one dollar, and you are only choosing a cash flow profile.
- If DSCR is binding, compute the interest-only loan and then check how much of the DSCR relief the next test strands. That stranded amount is value you cannot access.
- Solve for the breakeven reinvestment rate on the extra proceeds. If you do not have a specific, funded use for the money that clears it, the extra proceeds are not worth the deferred principal.
- Stress the exit on the refinance rate, not only the exit cap rate. Size a takeout loan on projected NOI at a rate 150 basis points above today’s and see which structure needs a check.
- For partial interest-only, confirm in writing whether DSCR is tested on the interest-only payment or a notional amortizing payment, and model the payment step-up against the NOI you actually expect in that year.
Red flags
- A quote that offers full-term interest-only on a deal where LTV is already the binding constraint. You are paying for optionality that produces no proceeds.
- A pro forma that shows interest-only cash flow through the hold but models the exit at today’s rates. That combination hides the entire cost of the structure.
- Partial interest-only with a payment step-up landing in a year with known lease rollover. Two sources of coverage pressure arriving together is how DSCR covenants get tripped.
- Extra interest-only proceeds budgeted to the equity checkbook rather than to a specific funded use. If the money is not earning above the breakeven rate, the structure is a loss.
- Any assumption that a performing asset can always be refinanced. In the grid above the asset performs exactly as underwritten and still requires a seven-figure check at an 8.75% takeout.
How QuadBlock can help
QuadBlock Capital provides bridge, transitional, and permanent financing from $250,000 to $30 million across multifamily, industrial, retail, self-storage, specialty, and ground-up residential, in every state except Oregon and Nevada. We will run the sizing waterfall on your deal under both structures and show you which test is actually binding before you sign a term sheet. Send the rent roll, trailing twelve, and your target structure to us at quadblockcapital.com and we will come back with the numbers.
This article is for general educational purposes and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Loan structures, underwriting standards, and tax treatment vary by lender, property, jurisdiction, and borrower circumstances, and the figures above are illustrative calculations based on stated assumptions rather than quoted terms. Consult your own tax advisor, attorney, and lender before making financing or investment decisions.
