Rate snapshot
| Fed funds target | 3.75% to 4.00% | Raised 25 bp Sept 16, 2026, effective Sept 17. First increase since the 2025 cutting cycle. |
| 2-year Treasury | 4.67% | Sept 17, 2026. Down 7 bp from 4.74% the day of the decision. |
| 5-year Treasury | 4.78% | Sept 17, 2026. Down 8 bp on the day. |
| 10-year Treasury | 4.94% | Sept 17, 2026. Down 7 bp from 5.01%, so long rates fell on a hike. |
| SOFR | 3.62% | Sept 16, 2026, the last print before the new target range took effect. |
| 3-month SOFR forwards | 4.24% / 4.61% | Year-end 2026 and year-end 2027, curve as of Sept 17, 2026. |
| Fed SEP median fed funds | 4.10% | Year-end 2026 and year-end 2027 medians, Sept 16, 2026 projections. |
The Fed raised the target range a quarter point on Tuesday, to 3.75% to 4.00%, and the vote was unanimous. For sponsors carrying floating-rate bridge debt, the index under that debt went up 25 basis points on Thursday and the forward curve says it is not finished. For sponsors shopping a fixed-rate quote, the five-year Treasury actually fell eight basis points on the news, to 4.78%.
That is the part worth sitting with. One decision moved the two sides of the fixed-versus-floating question in opposite directions. Floating debt got more expensive immediately and is priced to get more expensive still. Fixed debt, which prices off the intermediate Treasury, got slightly cheaper because the bond market read the hike as the Fed defending the inflation target rather than falling behind it.
So the question in front of a sponsor closing a $10M to $15M multifamily deal this month is not whether to hedge. If you take floating-rate debt, your lender will require a cap. The question is whether floating plus the cost of that cap still beats a fixed quote, and what strike you should actually buy. Below is one real-sized deal run both ways, with every figure computed from the curve as of September 17.
Why the forward curve matters more than the hike
A single 25 basis point move is not what decides this. What decides it is the path the market is charging you to float along. Three-month SOFR forwards as of September 17 sit at 4.24% for year-end 2026, 4.61% for year-end 2027, and 4.63% for year-end 2028.
Compare that to the Fed’s own September projections, where the median participant sees the fed funds rate at 4.10% at the end of both 2026 and 2027, easing to 3.90% in 2028 and 3.20% in the longer run. The market is pricing roughly 50 basis points more tightening through 2027 than the median policymaker is forecasting.
The two series are not identical. The forwards are three-month SOFR and the dots are the fed funds target midpoint. SOFR has been setting within a basis point of the midpoint, at 3.62% against a 3.625% midpoint on September 16, so the comparison holds directionally even though the instruments differ.
Why this matters for a borrower: when you take floating-rate debt, you do not get today’s SOFR for three years. You get the forward curve. The market is already charging you for the rate increases it expects, which is why a floating coupon that looks cheap on day one often is not cheap on average.
The deal
A 96-unit multifamily acquisition in a Southeast secondary market, light value-add, three-year hold. These are the inputs behind every number that follows.
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Units | 96 |
| Purchase price | $15,700,000 |
| Price per unit | $163,542 |
| Loan amount | $11,000,000 |
| Loan to purchase price | 70.1% |
| Term | 3 years, interest only |
| Going-in NOI | $985,000 |
| Going-in cap rate | 6.27% |
| Year-3 stabilized NOI | $1,190,000 |
The two structures
Fixed: priced off the September 17 five-year Treasury of 4.78% plus a 250 basis point spread, so 7.28%. Annual debt service of $800,800, going-in DSCR of 1.23x, stabilized DSCR of 1.49x.
Floating: SOFR plus 325 basis points, with a lender-required three-year SOFR cap on the full $11,000,000 notional. The coupon starts near 7.13% and rises along the forward curve from there. Both spreads are illustrative market assumptions used to make the comparison work, not QuadBlock quotes.
What a three-year SOFR cap actually costs
Cap premiums are not a fee schedule. A cap is a strip of quarterly options on SOFR, and the premium is driven by three things: how far the strike sits above the forward curve, how long the protection runs, and how volatile the market thinks rates will be. With forwards running in the 4.2% to 4.6% range, a 4.50% strike is close to at the money, which is expensive.
| Strike | Premium | % of loan | Cost per year (bp) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.00% | $235,466 | 2.14% | 71 |
| 4.25% | $197,571 | 1.80% | 60 |
| 4.50% | $165,387 | 1.50% | 50 |
| 5.00% | $115,896 | 1.05% | 35 |
| 5.50% | $81,658 | 0.74% | 25 |
A 4.50% strike costs $165,387 up front, which is 1.50% of the loan, or about 50 basis points a year added to the floating coupon. That is the number most sponsors leave out of the comparison, and it is large enough to change the answer.
Premiums also swing hard on volatility, which is the input a sponsor has no control over and usually never sees quoted. The same 4.50% strike ranges from $119,534 to $211,008 depending on where vol prints.
| Strike | 20% vol | 24% vol | 28% vol | 32% vol | 36% vol |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.00% | $195,733 | $215,328 | $235,466 | $255,909 | $276,509 |
| 4.50% | $119,534 | $142,469 | $165,387 | $188,243 | $211,008 |
| 5.00% | $71,360 | $93,386 | $115,896 | $138,694 | $161,650 |
The practical lesson is that a cap quote is a live market price with a short shelf life. If your quote is two weeks old, it is not a quote.
Running the deal five ways
Here is the three-year total interest cost under five rate paths, with the floating case carrying a 4.50% cap and the $165,387 premium included. Fixed total interest over three years is $2,402,400.
| Scenario | Avg capped SOFR | Floating interest | Plus cap premium | vs. fixed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market forward curve | 4.40% | $2,524,295 | $2,689,682 | +$287,282 |
| Fed SEP median path | 4.10% | $2,425,500 | $2,590,887 | +$188,487 |
| Sticky inflation, SOFR to 6.00% | 4.38% | $2,517,969 | $2,683,355 | +$280,955 |
| Hard landing, SOFR to 2.50% | 3.24% | $2,143,281 | $2,308,668 | -$93,732 |
| Flat at today’s 3.88% | 3.88% | $2,351,250 | $2,516,637 | +$114,237 |
Fixed wins in four of the five. Converted to an effective annual rate with the premium amortized over the term, the comparison is cleaner still.
| Scenario | Effective floating | Fixed | Fixed advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market forward curve | 8.15% | 7.28% | 87 bp |
| Fed SEP median path | 7.85% | 7.28% | 57 bp |
| Sticky inflation, SOFR to 6.00% | 8.13% | 7.28% | 85 bp |
| Hard landing, SOFR to 2.50% | 7.00% | 7.28% | -28 bp |
| Flat at today’s 3.88% | 7.63% | 7.28% | 35 bp |
Floating only wins on a hard landing, and it wins by 28 basis points. Fixed wins the base case by 87. That is an asymmetric payoff pointed the wrong way for anyone taking floating debt purely on cost.
The breakeven is already behind you
Solving for the average capped SOFR at which floating plus the cap ties the 7.28% fixed quote gives 3.53%. SOFR sets near 3.88% today, at the midpoint of the new target range, and the forward curve averages 4.40% over the next three years.
In other words, the breakeven is 35 basis points below where the index sits right now. Floating does not need rates to rise to lose this comparison. It needs them to fall roughly 35 basis points and stay there, which is not what the Fed projected on Tuesday and not what the curve is pricing.
What the cap actually pays back
It is worth separating the cap from the float decision, because sponsors routinely conflate them. The cap is insurance. Here is what the $165,387 premium buys under each path.
| Scenario | Uncapped interest | Capped interest | Cap payout | Net of premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market forward curve | $2,543,103 | $2,524,295 | $18,807 | -$146,579 |
| Fed SEP median path | $2,425,500 | $2,425,500 | $0 | -$165,387 |
| Sticky inflation, SOFR to 6.00% | $2,672,656 | $2,517,969 | $154,688 | -$10,699 |
| Hard landing, SOFR to 2.50% | $2,143,281 | $2,143,281 | $0 | -$165,387 |
| Flat at today’s 3.88% | $2,351,250 | $2,351,250 | $0 | -$165,387 |
The cap loses money in four of five scenarios, and roughly breaks even in the one where rates run to 6.00%. That is exactly how insurance is supposed to behave. Nobody expects their property insurance premium to come back, and nobody should underwrite a cap as an investment.
What the cap does is convert an unbounded liability into a known one. In the 6.00% scenario, it absorbed $154,688 of interest that would otherwise have hit the property’s cash flow in the years when the business plan is most fragile.
Picking a strike: start with the DSCR you must hold
Most sponsors pick a strike by working backward from what they are willing to spend on premium. That is the wrong order. Pick the strike from the DSCR you have to hold at the worst point, then price it.
| Strike | Capped all-in rate | Worst-case debt service | DSCR going-in | DSCR stabilized |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.00% | 7.25% | $797,500 | 1.24x | 1.49x |
| 4.25% | 7.50% | $825,000 | 1.19x | 1.44x |
| 4.50% | 7.75% | $852,500 | 1.16x | 1.40x |
| 5.00% | 8.25% | $907,500 | 1.09x | 1.31x |
| 5.50% | 8.75% | $962,500 | 1.02x | 1.24x |
On this deal, holding a 1.20x DSCR on going-in NOI in the worst case requires a strike of 4.21% or lower. Holding 1.25x requires 3.91%, which is below today’s SOFR and therefore prohibitively expensive. A 5.50% strike looks cheap at $81,658 until you notice it leaves the property at 1.02x if the cap is ever actually needed, which means it protects the lender’s recovery and not your distributions.
The tradeoff between adjacent strikes is easy to quantify. Moving from a 5.50% strike to a 4.50% strike costs an extra $83,728 in premium and saves $110,000 a year if SOFR sits at 5.50%. That is a payback of about nine months in the scenario you bought the cap for.
A working checklist before you sign
- Get the fixed quote and the floating quote priced on the same day off the same curve. A fixed quote from three weeks ago and a cap quote from this morning are not comparable.
- Add the amortized cap premium to the floating coupon before you compare. On this deal it is 50 basis points a year, and it is the single most commonly omitted number in the analysis.
- Solve for the breakeven average SOFR, then ask whether you actually believe rates go below it. If the breakeven is below spot, floating is a bet against both the Fed and the curve.
- Set the strike from your minimum DSCR at the weakest point of the business plan, not from a premium budget.
- Confirm the cap notional, term, and strike your lender requires in writing, and whether it must cover the full commitment or just funded principal.
- Price the replacement cap at each extension option now, not later. A one-year replacement cap at maturity is priced off the forward curve at that time, and it is often the most expensive cap you will ever buy.
- Check who owns the cap and who receives the payments. The cap is usually collaterally assigned to the lender, and payments may be swept rather than distributed.
- Confirm whether your lender requires a cap escrow or reserve for the replacement cap. That reserve is real cash that comes out of proceeds at close.
Red flags
A strike that only makes sense at the premium you wanted to pay is not a hedge. A cap that expires before the loan matures leaves an unhedged window that your lender will eventually make your problem. A cap purchased on the funded balance of a loan with substantial future funding leaves the later draws exposed.
And the most common one: comparing a floating coupon of 7.13% today against a 7.28% fixed quote and concluding floating is cheaper. It is cheaper for one quarter. Over three years, on this curve, it costs 87 basis points a year more.
Simplifications: interest-only on a constant $11,000,000 balance with no amortization or future funding. Cap premiums are model estimates computed with Black’s formula on quarterly caplets, using a forward path interpolated from published year-end three-month SOFR forwards as of September 17, 2026, with the front anchored at the 3.875% target midpoint, and a 28% lognormal volatility assumption in the base case. They are not dealer quotes, and live pricing will differ. Spreads of 325 basis points floating and 250 basis points fixed are illustrative market assumptions, not QuadBlock terms. Scenario paths are straight-line ramps from today’s level to the stated endpoint. Origination fees, cap broker fees, legal, and ISDA documentation costs are excluded and will add to the floating case.
How QuadBlock can help
QuadBlock Capital provides bridge, transitional, and permanent financing from $250K to $30M on multifamily, industrial, retail, self-storage, specialty assets, and ground-up SFR and townhome communities, with more than 30 closed transactions across every state except Oregon and Nevada. We are happy to run this comparison on your actual deal, including the cap sizing and the replacement cap at each extension. Send us the rent roll, T-12, and your business plan at quadblockcapital.com and we will come back with both structures priced off the same day’s curve.
This article is for general educational purposes and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Interest rate caps and other derivatives carry risks including counterparty risk, basis risk, and total loss of premium, and their suitability depends on facts specific to your transaction. Rate levels, forward curves, and cap premiums change daily and the figures here are as of the dates stated. Consult your own tax, legal, and financial advisors before entering into any financing or hedging transaction.
Sources
- Federal Reserve, FOMC statement, September 16, 2026
- Federal Reserve, Implementation Note, September 16, 2026
- Federal Reserve, Summary of Economic Projections, September 16, 2026
- Federal Reserve, Open Market Operations, target rate history
- U.S. Treasury, Daily Treasury Par Yield Curve Rates, September 2026
- Federal Reserve, H.15 Selected Interest Rates
- Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Secured Overnight Financing Rate
- Three-month SOFR forward curve, as of September 17, 2026
