Rate snapshot
| Fed funds target | 3.75% to 4.00% | Raised 25 bps on Sept. 16, 2026 |
| 10-year Treasury, today’s reference | 5.26% | Sept. 29, 2026 close |
| 10-year Treasury, 180 days ago | 4.35% | April 3, 2026, up 91 bps since |
| 7-year Treasury | 5.16% | Sept. 29, 2026, prices a 7-year industrial execution |
A sponsor who closed the sale of an industrial building on April 3 of this year has until today to take title to replacement property. On the day they signed, the 10-year Treasury was 4.35%. Today it is 5.26%. They identified their replacement in mid-May and underwrote it at a rate that no longer exists.
That gap is not just a pricing annoyance. It changes the amount of debt the replacement property can carry, and in a 1031 exchange the amount of debt you carry is a tax variable, not only a returns variable. Get it wrong and you owe tax on a transaction you executed specifically to avoid owing tax.
Here is the result that surprises people. On the exchange modeled below, the sponsor sells for $8,200,000, sheds $5,900,000 of debt, and walks to the qualified intermediary with $1,890,000. To land a comparable replacement property they have to write a new check for $1,455,629. The exchange is a capital call, not a liquidity event. And that check is the cheap option: declining to write it costs between $601,484 and $866,137 in tax and leaves them owning a $4.7 million building instead of an $8.3 million one.
The three conditions for full deferral
Section 1031 has applied only to real property held for business or investment use since 2018, so the asset class question is settled for commercial sponsors. What is not widely understood is how liabilities enter the calculation. Gain is deferred, in the IRS’s words, “but it is not tax-free,” and it is recognized to the extent you receive boot.
Boot is not only cash. The Form 8824 instructions define the taxable consideration to include “the excess, if any, of liabilities (including mortgages) assumed by the other party over the total of (a) any liabilities you assumed, (b) cash you paid to the other party, and (c) the FMV of the other (non-like-kind) property you gave up.” Read that netting formula carefully, because the practical rule falls straight out of it.
- Reinvest all of the net proceeds. Cash you keep is cash boot.
- Acquire replacement property of equal or greater value.
- Replace the debt you shed, with new debt or with new cash. The formula nets cash you pay in against debt you walk away from, so the two are interchangeable for this purpose.
Condition three is where today’s rates bite. The sponsor does not choose the replacement loan amount. The lender’s coverage test does.
The relinquished property
A small-bay industrial property in the Southeast, bought in 2016, refinanced in 2021 with a cash-out loan at a rate that made 72% leverage comfortable. The sponsor has taken depreciation for a decade and pulled tax-free proceeds once already, so basis is low and debt is high. That combination is common and it is exactly the profile that makes debt replacement hard.
| Relinquished property | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sale price | $8,200,000 |
| Selling costs at 5.0% | ($410,000) |
| Loan payoff, the debt being shed | ($5,900,000) |
| Net cash to the qualified intermediary | $1,890,000 |
| Adjusted basis | $2,600,000 |
| Gain realized | $5,190,000 |
Note the relationship between the two numbers that matter. The gain realized is $5,190,000, but the cash available to redeploy is only $1,890,000. The sponsor is carrying a large deferred tax liability on a small pile of cash, which is the normal end state of a successful hold.
Sizing the replacement loan
The replacement is a last-mile distribution facility at $8,300,000, a 6.50% cap rate on $539,500 of net operating income. Assume a 7.15% ten-year fixed loan, the 10-year Treasury at 5.26% plus a 189 basis point spread, on thirty-year amortization. The annual constant is 0.081049.
| Replacement loan sizing test | Maximum loan |
|---|---|
| LTV at 65% of $8,300,000 | $5,395,000 |
| DSCR at 1.30x on $539,500 NOI | $5,120,371 |
| Debt yield at 9.00% | $5,994,444 |
| Binding constraint: DSCR | $5,120,371 |
Coverage binds at $5,120,371. The sponsor shed $5,900,000 of debt and can only take on $5,120,371, a shortfall of $779,629. Had this loan priced at April’s 4.35% Treasury, the coverage test would not have bound at all and LTV would have allowed $5,395,000. The 91 basis point move cost roughly $275,000 of borrowing capacity on a single building.
Sources and uses
| Sources and uses | Amount |
|---|---|
| Uses: purchase price | $8,300,000 |
| Uses: acquisition costs at 2.0% | $166,000 |
| Total uses | $8,466,000 |
| Sources: exchange proceeds held by the QI | $1,890,000 |
| Sources: new first mortgage | $5,120,371 |
| Subtotal, sources in hand | $7,010,371 |
| New sponsor cash required | $1,455,629 |
The sponsor needs $1,455,629 that did not come out of the sale. Total equity in the replacement is $3,345,629, of which only 56% is recycled exchange proceeds. Anyone who modeled this as “roll my equity into a bigger building” has a funding problem to solve inside a 180-day window, and lining up a partner that late is how exchanges fail.
Why that check eliminates the tax
Now apply the netting formula. The sponsor shed $5,900,000 and took on $5,120,371, so gross debt relief is $779,629. But cash the taxpayer pays in offsets debt relief, and the sponsor is paying in $1,455,629.
| Boot calculation | Amount |
|---|---|
| Liabilities shed on the relinquished property | $5,900,000 |
| Liabilities assumed on the replacement | ($5,120,371) |
| Gross net debt relief | $779,629 |
| Less new cash paid in by the sponsor | ($1,455,629) |
| Net mortgage boot | $0 |
| Cash boot, proceeds not reinvested | $0 |
| Recognized gain | $0 |
| Gain deferred | $5,190,000 |
Full deferral, with $676,000 of cushion to spare. The sponsor did not need to match the old loan balance dollar for dollar with new debt. They needed to close the gap with something, and equity counts. That is the single most useful thing to know about debt replacement, and it is the opposite of the advice sponsors usually repeat to each other, which is that you must replace debt with debt.
What happens if the sponsor will not fund the gap
Suppose they decide not to write the check and instead buy whatever the exchange proceeds and a coverage-constrained loan will support on their own. Solve for the largest purchase price where uses equal available sources.
| Outcome | Fund the gap | Buy only what proceeds support |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | $8,300,000 | $4,688,805 |
| New loan | $5,120,371 | $2,892,581 |
| New sponsor cash | $1,455,629 | $0 |
| Net debt relief | $0 | $3,007,419 |
| Recognized gain | $0 | $3,007,419 |
| Tax at 20.0% | $0 | $601,484 |
| Tax at 23.8% | $0 | $715,766 |
| Tax at 25.0% | $0 | $751,855 |
| Tax at 28.8% | $0 | $866,137 |
Avoiding a $1,455,629 equity contribution produces a tax bill of $601,484 to $866,137 and a building $3,511,195 smaller than the one sold. Recognized gain is capped at gain realized, and here the $3,007,419 of debt relief sits well inside the $5,190,000 of gain, so all of it is taxable. The tax is shown across a range of effective rates because the character of recognized gain in a partial exchange, and therefore the rate applied to it, is specific to the taxpayer’s depreciation history and income.
How sensitive is this to the loan rate
| Replacement rate | Annual constant | New loan | New cash required | Boot if unfunded |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.15% | 0.073107 | $5,395,000 | $1,181,000 | $505,000 |
| 6.65% | 0.077036 | $5,387,107 | $1,188,893 | $512,893 |
| 7.15% | 0.081049 | $5,120,371 | $1,455,629 | $779,629 |
| 7.65% | 0.085142 | $4,874,226 | $1,701,774 | $1,025,774 |
| 8.15% | 0.089310 | $4,646,748 | $1,929,252 | $1,253,252 |
Two features are worth reading off this table. Between 6.15% and 6.65% the loan barely moves, because LTV is binding there and the rate is irrelevant to proceeds. From 7.15% upward every 50 basis points costs roughly $240,000 of loan and adds the same amount to the equity the sponsor must find. A sponsor who identified a replacement in May at a 6.15% indication and closes today at 7.15% has seen their required check grow by $274,629 for reasons that have nothing to do with the building.
Simplifications: the properties, prices, NOI, cap rates, basis, and loan terms are illustrative and not a QuadBlock quote. The 7.15% replacement rate is the cited Sept. 29, 2026 10-year Treasury plus an assumed 189 basis point spread; the 65% LTV, 1.30x DSCR, 9.00% debt yield floor, 5.0% selling costs, and 2.0% acquisition costs are assumptions that vary by lender, sponsor, and asset. Tax is shown at four illustrative effective rates rather than computed, because the split of recognized gain between unrecaptured section 1250 gain and long-term capital gain, the ordering rules applied to it, net investment income tax, state tax, and any suspended losses are all taxpayer-specific. Depreciation recapture on the relinquished property, partnership-level allocations, and the identification rules limiting how many replacement properties may be named are outside this model.
Running the clock
The deadlines are strict and the second one is commonly misread. Identification is due in writing within 45 days of transferring the relinquished property, and the IRS is specific that it must be delivered to someone directly involved in the exchange, not to your accountant or attorney. Receipt of the replacement is due by the 180th day, or your return due date including extensions, whichever comes first.
- Before you list, model the replacement loan at today’s coverage test, not at your existing loan’s leverage. The output you need is the debt gap.
- Convert the debt gap into an equity number and confirm the source of that equity in writing before day one.
- Engage the qualified intermediary before closing the sale. Touching the proceeds ends the exchange.
- Order the replacement property’s third-party reports early. A property condition report that triggers a repair escrow reduces loan proceeds and widens the gap.
- Identify more than one replacement property, and identify at least one you can close without a partner.
- Get a rate lock or a spread lock as early as the lender allows, because the sensitivity above is your equity exposure.
- Have your tax advisor run Form 8824 on the actual structure before you go hard, not in April of next year.
Red flags
- High leverage on the relinquished property combined with low basis. This is the classic setup for a debt gap you cannot fund.
- A replacement priced at a lower cap rate than the property sold. Less NOI per dollar means less debt per dollar and a wider gap.
- Assuming debt must be replaced with debt. It does not, and believing otherwise leads sponsors to over-lever a replacement they should have funded with equity.
- A replacement loan quoted but not locked with 60 days left on the clock.
- Seller financing or an assumption on the replacement that changes who is treated as assuming which liability. Get that into Form 8824 before signing.
- Counting on a refinance of the replacement property right after closing to get your equity back. A cash-out taken as part of the exchange plan invites scrutiny; discuss timing with counsel.
How QuadBlock can help
QuadBlock Capital places bridge, transitional, and permanent financing from $250,000 to $30 million across industrial, multifamily, retail, self-storage, specialty, and ground-up residential, in every state except Oregon and Nevada. On an exchange we will size the replacement loan against today’s coverage test up front, so you know the debt gap and the equity it implies before the 45-day clock starts rather than after. Send the relinquished property’s payoff, the replacement’s trailing twelve, and your closing date to quadblockcapital.com and we will give you the gap in writing.
This article is for general educational purposes and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Section 1031 exchanges are technical, deadline-driven transactions and a failed exchange is generally not curable after the fact. The boot and deferral figures above are simplified illustrations that omit depreciation recapture character, ordering rules, net investment income tax, state and local tax, partnership allocations, and identification limits. Loan terms, agency and lender guidelines, and pricing change frequently and the figures here are not an offer, commitment, or quote to lend. Engage a qualified intermediary before closing your sale, and consult your own tax advisor and attorney on your specific facts before relying on any of this.
Sources
- IRS, Instructions for Form 8824, Like-Kind Exchanges
- IRS Fact Sheet FS-2008-18, Like-Kind Exchanges Under IRC Section 1031
- IRS, About Form 8824, Like-Kind Exchanges
- U.S. Department of the Treasury, Daily Treasury Par Yield Curve Rates, September 2026
- U.S. Department of the Treasury, Daily Treasury Par Yield Curve Rates, April 2026
- Federal Reserve, FOMC Statement, September 16, 2026
